Userid: Password:
BoaterTalk
BoaterTalk
NRS
BoaterTalk: The International Information Site for the Whitewater Paddler

Forum
Forum: BoaterTalk

Clear all "New" markers Turn on extra data

Thread View Frames View Board View

question Thinking of finally replacing my "Y". Suggestions for *similar* boats to replace it with? New

Forum: BoaterTalk
Date: Apr 11 2008, 12:39 GMT
From: CintiBud

I love my Y but it's showing its age (9 years! no wonder they stopped using crosslinked plastic.). I intend on trying out many different boats but looking for some suggestions for something with the good aspects of the Y (stability, predictability, easy to roll, playful for its type, etc) while improving on its drawbacks (outfitting, tight exit, slow, heavy, etc). At 230, uh plus, pounds and 6 ft, I'm a bit over the limit for some designs.

Thanks in advance for the suggestions on boats to focus on.

Add Message

note I think you should try an Everest...but as always demo...demo...demo ditchbitch New
note dang it!  I told you somebody would say it. mtnsport New
smile I'm sure it's just a matter of time till someone says Burn or at your size an Everest mtnsport New
feedback Mystic is probably the closest. I liked the Nomad as well. . . Footer New
note Time for an Everest! granolapaddler New
idea The SuperHero is a planing-hulled river-runner/creeker... yakdaddy New
note The  Remix 79 is worth a look <NT> whirlybird New
note Jefe G caliproduct.com New
feedback Fluid Solo is solid as a rock. Gavin_Rains New
note For creekers with playboat hulls check out thunder or scud arrmike New
smile Thanks everyone! I'm going to be demoing my butt off. CintiBud New
note The new Superhero should be at the top of your demo list :) BoyGenius New
note Not to open the edge vs no edge on a creeker debate..... greyhound1 New
note Thanks Chris, I'll call <NT> CintiBud New
feedback If you've been paddling a Y you'll love the Burn. Pinecricker New
note The Superhero might be your best bet for a "replacement" but for the attributes you listed TheBroncoKid New
note The Gangster as a creeker option for a 230 lber? BobbyPeru New
note suggested paddler weight is from 180-250 so he's within the range, plus, as a fellow 230er TheBroncoKid New
note I tend to agree with that thinking. Thanks! <NT> CintiBud New
note The Gangster would be a "play-creeker" for your weight... axr6 New
note The Gangster looked good with 160 lb folks boating it.......I would think it would be underwater with an extra 70 lbs. <NT> Bradley New
disagree I've actually paddled it at 230 <NT> TheBroncoKid New
note Y replacement, 230lb: ClayW New
smile Love my Hercules! Bradley New
note Just to throw another one into the mix... Volitan New
smile With all of the suggestions, if you were to demo all, you MIGHT have a new boat by 2010. <NT> hardboater New
th_up Pyranha Everest asb New
note H3 255 is very similar willdabeast New
smile yes... try the... decker New
note Having had 3 Y's(and still one hanging on) here is what I found that can replace it skyboyroller@hotmail.com New
note Sure I remember you Daryl, thanks for the suggestions! <NT> CintiBud New
Fluid Kayaks

Add Message