Userid: Password:
BoaterTalk
BoaterTalk
BoaterTalk: The International Information Site for the Whitewater Paddler

Forum
Forum: BoaterTalk
NRS

Clear all "New" markers Turn on extra data

Thread View Frames View Board View

note Apples-n-Oranges New

Forum: BoaterTalk
Re: note Glass Freestyle playboat - guigui-prod Bradley New
Re: note Looked good at World Cup until 1/2 of them broke BoyGenius New
Re: note Wasn't Augsberg breaking hurricanes & kendos in the 95 world cup? Bradley New
Re: gack Ask WaveSport about the warranty on the composite boats:) Class7 New
Re: note People get so worked up about how durable glass is, and there are a bunch of 20 year old squirt boats out there..... Bradley New
Date: Nov 10 2008, 23:40 GMT
From: RodeoClown

RodeoClown
There's a big difference between a 6/7 squirtboat and an ultralight carbon composite playboat.  The squirtboat is going to be way tougher, and a lot of those 20 year old boats either weren't used hard, or put back together a few times.  The anecdotal evidence about squitboats is good testament to the possibility of durable composites, but there are still a few problems.  One is that the shape of most squirtboat hulls allows the stress to be spread out, whereas a hard chined design concentrates the stress at the chines.

I've also hit enough rocks, and seen enough other people hit rocks, in both plastic boats and squirt boats to know that the hits I take in my playboat are much harder, and would put cracks in my squirt. (not just cause I can take a harder hit, there just a lot of force when you hit bottom on a loop).

I like the idea of the composite playboat, but it's really limited in use.  I'd say that if I had one, I'd probably use it about 10% of the time I use my plastic boat- there are just a lot of shallow playspots out there.

But what do I know?
Jeremy

Add Message

th_up Jeremy, I'd say you have the most informed opinion on here. Bradley New
note I paddled with Bryan on the Gauley when he paddled the carbon Project RodeoClown New
note How about the susquehana when it starts pumping? Bradley New
note Some good, some bad RodeoClown New
note Any thoughts on the bamboo cloth that Corran is using in surfboards for a "glass" boat? <NT> Bradley New
note I've looked into it a little bit RodeoClown New
th_up Another thing to consider: composites show damage *differently* DavidWeber New
NRS

Add Message