Userid: Password:
BoaterTalk
BoaterTalk
NOC
BoaterTalk: The International Information Site for the Whitewater Paddler

Forum
Forum: LiquidLounge
NRS

Clear all "New" markers Turn on extra data

Thread View Frames View Board View

note "Silverado" or "The Shootist"? New

Forum: LiquidLounge
Date: May 16 2008, 16:47 GMT
From: Oci-One.Kanubi

 
I'm a fan of westerns.  I have about five Wyatt Earps (Kurt Russell, Kevin Costner, James Garner, Henry Fonda, and someone else), three or four Billy the Kids (Emilio Estevez, Kris Kristofferson, Paul Newman), a couple of James/Younger Gangs (Carradines/Keaches, and another, and expecting to get the new one when it hits DVD in the next few months).  I have all of Clint Eastwood's westerns ("The Outlaw Josey Wales" is a standout) and a number of John Wayne's ("Stagecoach" is dated and "She Tied a Yellow Ribbon" is really dated, but the Rooster Cogburn movies were OK).  I also have "High Noon", "Shane", "The Wild Bunch" and a couple others of the classics.  Sergio Leone's "Once Upon a Time in the West" was terrific, and I have the entire "Lonesome Dove" saga, including the two years of the Canadian TV series.  I just watched "3:10 to Yuma" and found it better than acceptable, but not great.  I like the Sam Elliot/Tom Sellick "Sacketts" movies, and I thought "Quigley Down Under" was nearly as good as "Silverado" and "The Shootist."

I really do like the more recent ones better; higher budgets, better production values, and a quantum leap in the craft of acting over the last 50 years have all combined to make more recent movies much slicker and more believable.

So, how come all you Limpid Loungers hate westerns?

-Richard, His Kanubic Travesty
--
======================================================================
Richard Hopley                                  Winston-Salem, NC, USA
      Nothing really matters except Boats, Sex, and Rock'n'Roll
.                    rhopley[at]earthlink[dot]net
  OK, OK; computer programming for scientific research also matters
.                     rhopley[at]wfubmc[dot]edu
======================================================================

Add Message

note check out "The Proposition" if you haven't already <NT> thumper New
more Is that the Aussie movie? <NT> davegg New
note It is.  And it seems as if I've got it. Oci-One.Kanubi New
smile fine. how about The Quick & The Dead <NT> thumper New
th_up thatn kicked butt. GCA_Steve New
smile horrid movie. Totally, unbelievable. Waste of some good actors. <NT> davegg New
smile "horrid"? GCA_Steve New
more Seraphim Falls thumper New
note Another one pitting an Aussie actor against a Brit (Irish, in this case) actor... Oci-One.Kanubi New
note Pretty good, but not a Western. Oci-One.Kanubi New
note "High Plains Drifter" has always been my favorite. GCA_Steve New
feedback "Unforgiven" and "Siiverado" are my top two. "The Searchers" is my favorite John Wayne western <NT> Gordo New
note Yeh, "Unforgiven" is pretty good.  I keep meaning to get "The Searchers." Oci-One.Kanubi New
feedback Silverado sucked. My favs:  "The Shootist", "Unforgiven", "Tombstone"  in no davegg New
note Maybe you missed the point of "Silverado" Gordo New
note re: melodrama -- I understood that. I still didn't like even though I like a davegg New
note That's really the definition of melodrama, it's good vs. evil with no gray areas in between <NT> Gordo New
smile She Wore a Yellow Ribbon........(you're into Tony Orlando, eh?)...... tomcat New
note What was the name of the western with Mr.DeadLegs New
note Warren Beatty?  Is he that guy that squealed like a pig? <NT> Oci-One.Kanubi New
note thatn wasn't no western neither. GCA_Steve New
more "McCabe and Mrs. Miller"? lrcable New
note Hate 'em?  LOVE 'em!  Once upon a time in the West! The Wild Bunch! They call; me nobody! laughingtotem New
note Sorry, it's "My name is Nobody." laughingtotem New
note Holy Crap!  They call me Trinity is in the public domain and the whole movie is available online! laughingtotem New
note "Trinity is Still my Name" <NT> rroberts New
note That's the sequel.  Any good? <NT> laughingtotem New
note Every bit as good as Trinity.  I mean, let's face it, it ain't high drama! <NT> rroberts New
smile the Life & Times of Judge Roy Bean and Little Big Man russellfork New
note I liked Kevin Kostner as his role resembling a Kender in Silverado. Wilko New
smile "The Shootist" has a better story line lrcable New
note Silverado is fantastic.   I also watch/love westerns, much to my wife's dismay!  The Man from Snowy River is also good. Terrell New
note A comedic bend catinhat New
note outlaw josey wales roscoepwavetrain New
th_up "Course, it was on TV but Lonesome Dove was real good.  So is Deadwood on HBO. <NT> ckelly New
th_up "Course, it was on TV but Lonesome Dove was real good.  So is Deadwood on HBO. ckelly New
smile Unforgiven and Silverado are two of my favorite movies. GRITS New
th_up love Quigley julesagogo New
NOC

Add Message